Quick Answer
Use needs-based questions, offer two options, and script conversational bridges that make upgrades feel natural.
Upselling Secrets: Training Scripts That Don't Sound Pushy
Upselling is service, not sleaze. Guests appreciate guidance when it is rooted in their preferences. Use these scripts and drills to increase spend per head by 10% while keeping reviews glowing.
Step 1: Start With Questions
Teach staff to ask one discovery question per interaction:
- "Are you in the mood for something refreshing or cosy tonight?"
- "Celebrating anything or just a chilled catch-up?" Their answer dictates the upsell lane.
Step 2: Offer Two Curated Options
People freeze when given six choices. Script two contrasting upgrades:
- "If you fancy local, our Wye Valley pale is flying. If you want silky, the milk stout just landed."
- "Chef can add smoked bone marrow to that steak or we can swap to the dry-aged cut for £4 extra."
Step 3: Use Bridge Phrases
Provide connective tissue so the upsell feels like a favour:
- "Most regulars pair that with..."
- "Because it is chilly, guests are loving..."
- "To make it a bit special, we can..."
Step 4: Drill Daily
Run 5-minute role plays at lineup. One person plays a guest archetype (first date, rugby team, solo diner) and the other must ask, recommend, and close with confidence. Rotate pairs so everyone practices.
Step 5: Track and Celebrate
Add an upsell KPI to the whiteboard: desserts attached, premium pours sold, large wine upgrades. Celebrate streaks with instant rewards and share exact phrasing that worked.
Mini FAQ
What if guests say no? Thank them and move on. A polite refusal still shows you care. The goal is relevance, not pressure.
Should I script entire conversations? Provide frameworks, not word-for-word lines. Authenticity matters; the team should adapt scripts to their voice once they grasp the structure.
Great upselling feels like matchmaking. Nail the approach and guests will thank you for spending more.
Need Help Implementing These Ideas?
I've proven these strategies work at The Anchor and will start training other pubs from September 2025. Let's chat about your specific situation - no sales pitch, just licensee to licensee.
Get Help Now
Peter Pitcher
Founder & Licensee
Licensee of The Anchor and founder of Orange Jelly. Helping pubs thrive with proven strategies.
Learn more about Peter →Keep exploring proven tactics
Previously
location-challenges • 28 August 2026
Village Pub in a Dying Village? Survival Strategies That Actually Work
"The village is dying, Peter. Twenty houses for sale, Post Office gone, bus service cut. We're next." That was my neighbor, pint in hand, delivering what felt...
Read articleUp next
Turnaround Playbooks • 14 August 2026
The Turnaround Playbook: How Independent Bars Bounce Back Fast
The Turnaround Playbook: How Independent Bars Bounce Back Fast There is a predictable rhythm to every successful turnaround. When I mentor landlords who feel...
Read article